Curtain Up: Nine Happy Neighbors Watch ‘Twelve Angry Men’

Share this:

Attending a play or concert with a friend is always fun, but what happens when you get nine neighbors together and make a group trip to Laguna Playhouse to watch a weekend matinee performance of “Twelve Angry Men?”

Last Saturday, nine neighbors (including me) who frequently meet with our dogs at a local park left our pooches at home and made the trek to Laguna Beach to enjoy a production of the classic 1954 play “Twelve Angry Men,” a courtroom drama written by playwright Reginald Rose in which a dozen jurors decide the fate of a young man accused of murder. What will the verdict be?

Nine happy neighbors attending a play at Laguna Playhouse

This suspenseful (and occasionally funny) thriller pits passionate jurors against one another in a surprisingly timely examination of the American justice system while exploring personal prejudices that society still grapples with today.

Rose wrote “Twelve Angry Men” after his stint on jury duty in New York. His well-written play obviously struck a nerve: he won an Emmy Award for the TV version of “Twelve Angry Men,” and received an Academy Award nomination for the 1957 film version starring Henry Fonda.

The Laguna Playhouse production, which runs through Oct. 22, features 12 actors who have a variety of TV, stage and film work in their thespian hats, experience that lends itself well to the challenges of a single-set drama that was penned more than 60 years ago.

It was with great anticipation that we nine theater lovers took our seats as the lights dimmed. We were not disappointed—in fact, you could say we were thrilled by the production, which runs 100 minutes with no intermission so the tension remains high the entire time.

We, and the rest of the nearly sold-out audience, gave the performance a hearty standing ovation at its conclusion.

We strolled downtown to The Lumberyard Restaurant to grab dinner and discuss the play. We agreed that it was a fabulous production, mainly because the actors created convincing characters and the play built in suspense minute by minute.

“I thought the actors came alive as real people—very believable,” stated Pam Logan, while her husband Peter noted that “the play had the intensity needed to do the old classic justice. I was pleased with the diversity of the cast and the high level of experienced actors they chose. Well done!”

“We sat spellbound from beginning until end,” added Don Wittenberg. “Each member of the cast WAS the character, displaying his courage, prejudices or inner demons. The play is so well written with key evidence revealed gradually and then argued. Magnificent!”

We also agreed that the themes of racial intolerance and bigotry that crept into the play are (unfortunately) as timely now as they were in the 1950s.

Lumberyard was also a hit. We ordered the famous Planks (deep fried zucchini) to start, then a variety of salads, burgers, meatloaf and ahi tuna sandwiches. The portions are so generous at Lumberyard that several people in our group asked for doggie bags (which means our spoiled dogs got even more spoiled that night).

By the way, the cast of “Twelve Angry Men” features former Laguna Playhouse artistic director Andy Barnicle convincingly playing the role of an elderly juror, Daniel Berlin (“Hairspray,” Laguna Playhouse), Richard Burgi (“The Sentinel,” “Desperate Housewives”), John Colella (“Revolver” at Celebration Theatre, “Niagara Falls” at Theatre of NOTE), Rick Cosnett (“The Flash”), Seamus Dever (“Castle”), Matthew Henerson (“Ah, Wilderness” at A Noise Within), Mueen Jahan (“Bombay Dreams” on Broadway), John Massey (“The Odd Couple” at Laguna Playhouse), David Nevell (“Peter and the Starcatcher,” “Arms and the Man” at South Coast Rep), Erik Odom (“Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn – Part 2”), Dennis Renard (“Othello” and “Proof” at UCLA) and Tony Sancho (“Hephaistos” at the Getty Villa).

Bravo to them all!

Tickets are $45 – $80 and can be purchased online at or by calling (949) 497-ARTS (2787). Group rates are also available—tell them the Nine Neighbors sent you.

Share this: